=========================================== #opendaylight-group-policy: gbp_status_arch =========================================== Meeting started by tbachman at 18:00:18 UTC. The full logs are available at http://meetings.opendaylight.org/opendaylight-group-policy/2014/gbp_status_arch/opendaylight-group-policy-gbp_status_arch.2014-11-07-18.00.log.html . Meeting summary --------------- * agenda (tbachman, 18:01:46) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Group_Policy:Sub-Groups:STATUS#Team_Meeting Agenda for today’s Status/Arch meeting (tbachman, 18:03:00) * Review of cleaned up Trello (tbachman, 18:03:13) * alagalah condensed the number of cards by making checklists (tbachman, 18:05:49) * The “Super-cala-fragalistic important” category contains items that were deferred from the Helium release (tbachman, 18:06:31) * Team members are encouraged to pick cards from this Trello category first (tbachman, 18:07:16) * LINK: https://trello.com/b/yc0xHFlv/opendaylight-groupbasedpolicy-lithium Lithium Trello board for GBP (tbachman, 18:07:48) * Lithium Release plan (tbachman, 18:08:36) * shares a template for the Li Release Plan (link below) (alagalah, 18:09:45) * LINK: https://docs.google.com/a/noironetworks.com/spreadsheets/d/15nBWBNxCy3518o3tj808HjKaz2n7qyUgxQWDUKZEmy4/edit#gid=0 (alagalah, 18:09:52) * ACTION: tbachman to link to GBP wiki and email -dev list (alagalah, 18:10:06) * alagalah notes that Offset0 and Offset2 are the easiest to grok.. ie Offset0: others depend on you, you don't depend on other Offset2: you depend on others, no one depends on 2. Offset1 is a little more hazy (as in I haven't heard a definitive defn) (alagalah, 18:13:28) * WIP (tbachman, 18:18:26) * alagalah working on design for the PolicyException Handler (tbachman, 18:19:12) * Similar to the FCAPs model for alarming (tbachman, 18:19:21) * This represents an alarm that can change over time (tbachman, 18:19:39) * Alarm Severity Assignment Profile model (ASAP), which is an operational policy (tbachman, 18:20:33) * The severity of the inability to get that policy can be augmented by the operational policy (tbachman, 18:21:30) * alagalah invites those with Telcordia/FCAPs experience to help out (tbachman, 18:23:13) * dbainbri asks how to refer to individual cards on the Trello board (tbachman, 18:24:25) * alagalah says that each card has a name (e.g. card 37) and a link (tbachman, 18:24:39) * LINK: https://trello.com/c/hjSnav8q - Exception handling trello card (alagalah, 18:25:45) * LINK: https://trello.com/c/V8RqRzlC - Exception handling coding trello card (alagalah, 18:26:03) * LINK: https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-smith-opflex-00 Original OpFlex RFC (tbachman, 18:29:07) * POSTMAN files on wiki (tbachman, 18:29:25) * ACTION: alagalah to push POSTMAN files to the wiki (tbachman, 18:29:48) * POSTMAN files can be used to exercise REST APIs with GBP (tbachman, 18:30:04) * Update on OpenStack Paris (tbachman, 18:30:41) * LINK: https://www.openstack.org/summit/openstack-paris-summit-2014/session-videos/presentation/group-based-policy-extension-for-networking Group Based Policy Extension for Networking video at OpenStack Paris summit (tbachman, 18:30:53) * LINK: https://www.openstack.org/summit/openstack-paris-summit-2014/session-videos/presentation/opendaylight-and-openstack-developer-panel OpenStack and OpenDaylight developer panel video at OpenStack Paris summit (tbachman, 18:30:54) * LINK: https://www.openstack.org/summit/openstack-paris-summit-2014/session-videos/presentation/sponsor-demo-theater-one-convergence-policy-driven-network-service-delivery One Convergence: Policy Driven Network Service Delivery video at OpenStack Paris summit (tbachman, 18:30:55) * LINK: https://www.openstack.org/summit/openstack-paris-summit-2014/session-videos/presentation/neutron-roundtable-overlay-or-full-sdn Neutron Round Table: Overlay or Full SDN? video at OpenStack Paris summit (tbachman, 18:30:56) * LINK: (tbachman, 18:30:57) * LINK: : https://www.openstack.org/summit/openstack-paris-summit-2014/session-videos/presentation/sponsor-demo-theater-opendaylight-opendaylight-and-the-rise-of-open-source-sdn OpenDaylight and the Rise of OpenSource SDN video at OpenStack Paris summit (tbachman, 18:33:08) * HOW TOs (alagalah, 18:33:48) * alagalah asks what we’re missing in order to make the project more consumable and easier to use? (tbachman, 18:34:16) * alagalah notes we have wiki pages describing the arch and the POC (tbachman, 18:34:39) * alagalah says we’re missing a component map, along the lines of other projects (e.g. MD-SAL) (tbachman, 18:35:16) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Group_Policy:Architecture GBP Arch wiki page (tbachman, 18:35:26) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Group_Policy:Architecture/Policy_Model GBP Policy Model wiki page (tbachman, 18:35:44) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Group_Policy:Architecture/OVS_Overlay GBP OVS Overlay wiki page (tbachman, 18:36:07) * mickey_spiegel says the main thing that’s missing is more examples and use cases of policies and how you would use the model to do different things (tbachman, 18:36:51) * alagalah says that was one of the goals of the latest iteration of the POC (i.e. dockerization), but notes that we could do morehere (tbachman, 18:37:17) * alagalah asks what use cases mickey_spiegel would like to see (tbachman, 18:38:16) * mickey_spiegel says he created a list before the Helium release, and will provide that (tbachman, 18:38:29) * tbachman says there are use cases that Sanjay provided (tbachman, 18:39:19) * mickey_spiegel says that those were a bit more complex, and that simpler use cases would probably be more useful (tbachman, 18:39:35) * alagalah says the current POC is only a “two-tier”, so maybe a 3-tier might be helpful (tbachman, 18:40:18) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/images/8/83/Policy_Usecases.pptx Use cases created by Sanjay (tbachman, 18:40:29) * dbainbri says component maps, API doc, tutorials are all very useful (tbachman, 18:41:53) * ACTION: alagalah to document the FLOW of information through GBP and the OFOverlayRenderer in a diagram to help augment or show at a high-level the information that is represented in the Architecture wiki information (alagalah, 18:44:50) * ACTION: alagalah also how it interacts with all of ODL ie openflowplugin or indeed how to get it from a RESTcall etc (alagalah, 18:45:29) * ACTION: alagalah to make a User level walk thru (5min preso type level) (alagalah, 18:46:06) * Andrew has some ideas for the GUI/UI (tbachman, 18:48:28) * initial thought for policies and contracts is sort of a google maps concept (tbachman, 18:48:43) * you could zoom in to endpoints, zoom out to policies between data centers, etc. (tbachman, 18:49:21) * The other dimension to the UI is specifying policies/contracts (tbachman, 18:49:41) Meeting ended at 18:54:33 UTC. Action items, by person ----------------------- * alagalah * alagalah to push POSTMAN files to the wiki * alagalah to document the FLOW of information through GBP and the OFOverlayRenderer in a diagram to help augment or show at a high-level the information that is represented in the Architecture wiki information * alagalah also how it interacts with all of ODL ie openflowplugin or indeed how to get it from a RESTcall etc * alagalah to make a User level walk thru (5min preso type level) * tbachman * tbachman to link to GBP wiki and email -dev list People present (lines said) --------------------------- * tbachman (55) * alagalah (10) * odl_meetbot (7) Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4