===============================
#opendaylight-meeting: odlforge
===============================


Meeting started by colindixon at 18:10:19 UTC.  The full logs are
available at
http://meetings.opendaylight.org/opendaylight-meeting/2014/odlforge/opendaylight-meeting-odlforge.2014-08-14-18.10.log.html
.



Meeting summary
---------------

* LINK: http://ci.openstack.org/stackforge.html  (cdub, 18:10:26)
* the core idea is to give people a place to do real work with code
  without having to go through project proposal project  (colindixon,
  18:11:45)
* it’s also a great way to start and maintain things until they become
  good incubation projects and have the TSC have good data about how
  much interest there is  (colindixon, 18:12:42)
* LINK: https://github.com/odlforge  (cdub, 18:12:57)
* key point is that it *is not* actual ODL code, it isn’t shipped in
  releases, or officially blessed  (colindixon, 18:13:00)
* the above link makes that clear by differentiating between
  git.opendaylight.org, our mirror at github.com/opendaylight, and
  github.com/odlforge  (colindixon, 18:14:08)
* LINK:
  https://meetings.opendaylight.org/opendaylight-meeting/2014/odlforge/opendaylight-meeting-odlforge.2014-08-14-18.10.log.txt
  (colindixon, 18:15:10)
* so far, the only thing that has been done is to create that empty
  github page  (colindixon, 18:15:32)
* edwarnicke asks why we stood it up on github instead of our own
  infrastructure  (colindixon, 18:15:57)
* cdub says that the github is there just for the same reason our
  current github thing is there, i.e., to mirror our own internal gerrit
  things  (colindixon, 18:16:54)
* tykeal says that his current thoughts are to have only one gerrit set
  up with a separate tree named “forge” or “odlforge”  (colindixon,
  18:17:29)
* edwarnicke expresses some worry that that might not be enough
  separation since forge patches would show up looking similar to
  regular projects  (colindixon, 18:18:34)
* tykeal’s thoghts on how to get this working  (colindixon, 18:21:33)
  * current ideas: separate tree in a current gerrit  (cdub, 18:21:53)
  * right now the thought was a separate tree in gerrit for two reasons:
    (1) people can keep their current profile and (2) less
    infrastructure to set up  (colindixon, 18:22:07)
  * there would be a wholly separate jenkins for forge with something
    like jenkins-forge.opendaylight.org or something similar
    (colindixon, 18:22:59)
  * for bugzilla, there’s no way to clearly tag things as forge and
    tykeal really doesn’t want to set up another bugzilla  (colindixon,
    18:23:32)
  * likely punt on bz (hard to separate and hard to set up new one)
    (cdub, 18:23:38)
  * use dev list w/ forge project [topic] (no new lists!)  (cdub,
    18:24:05)
  * last thing is mailing lists, tykeal says he’s adamantly opposed to
    giving them their own mailing lists  (colindixon, 18:24:34)
  * separate repositories for forge artifacts  (colindixon, 18:25:10)
  * nexus...opendaylight-forge repo and use org.opendaylight.forge
    namespace  (cdub, 18:25:11)
  * gerrit separation concern (a cset gerrit link doesn't indicate the
    project until you click on it)  (cdub, 18:30:34)
  * cdub proposes the idea of setting up a single project to test out
    things like infrastructure, etc.  (tbachman, 18:41:55)
  * edwarnicke expresses concern about separation  (tbachman, 18:42:04)
  * tykeal believes the separation issue boils down to gerrit
    (tbachman, 18:42:19)
  * edwarnick asks if we’ll have a separate gerrit for odlforge
    (tbachman, 18:42:29)
  * tykeal says that if we go that route, we will not allow imports of
    history  (tbachman, 18:42:48)
  * b/c there is no way to confirm that the same SSO ID exists in both
    gerrit systems at the same time  (tbachman, 18:43:11)
  * be sure odl projects can't depend on odlforge projects  (cdub,
    18:46:17)



Meeting ended at 18:50:46 UTC.



People present (lines said)
---------------------------

* colindixon (27)
* cdub (12)
* rexpugh (7)
* tbachman (6)
* odl_meetbot (5)
* Madhu_ (2)
* tykeal (1)
* dfarrell07 (1)
* phrobb (0)
* edwarnicke (0)



Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4