14:01:49 <hwoarang> #startmeeting Cross Community CI
14:01:49 <collabot`> Meeting started Wed Feb 21 14:01:49 2018 UTC.  The chair is hwoarang. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:01:49 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
14:01:49 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'cross_community_ci'
14:02:00 <hwoarang> so who is around this sunny day?
14:02:07 <joekidder> #info Joe Kidder
14:02:21 <david_Orange> #info David Blaisonneau
14:02:22 <joekidder> not sunny here in Boston area, but it IS warm!
14:03:04 <mardim> #info Dimitrios Markou
14:03:10 <hwoarang> lets move on people can join as we move along
14:03:27 <pkaralis> #info Panagiotis Karalis
14:03:32 <jmorgan1> #info Jack Morgan
14:03:36 <hwoarang> agenda is at the usual place https://etherpad.opnfv.org/p/xci-meetings
14:03:49 <hwoarang> #topic High Priority Items - functest
14:04:29 <electrocucaracha> #info Victor Morales
14:04:41 <hwoarang> #info functest still fails in one api_check test (test_add_remove_volume)
14:05:01 <hwoarang> #info proposed patches for snaps project
14:05:03 <hwoarang> #link  https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/q/status:open+project:snaps+branch:master+topic:increase-api-timeout
14:05:41 <hwoarang> Fatih told me that one more test is failing but i haven't managed to reproduce it yet so i have nothing else to add on that topic
14:05:56 <hwoarang> anybody else want to say anything about functest?
14:06:21 <hwoarang> ok then moving on
14:06:37 <hwoarang> #topic High Priority Items - baremetal
14:06:40 <hwoarang> david_Orange: ^
14:06:44 <hwoarang> stage is yours
14:07:41 <david_Orange> sorry i had a call
14:07:52 <david_Orange> things are moving on barematal
14:08:12 <hwoarang> is it time for us to jump on reviews?
14:08:29 <david_Orange> on lfpod4, i had an issue with MAAS for the jumphost
14:09:09 <david_Orange> i solved it and i had it also for bifrost, LF stop a MAAS on another pod and now it is solved, there is a big network isolation issue
14:09:30 <david_Orange> but i just have 5 baremetal nodes depoloyed with an ubuntu
14:09:38 <hwoarang> #info lfpod4 issue with MAAS on jumphost resolved
14:10:20 <david_Orange> on ericsson pod2, i could not bootup nodes, it is an issue linked with the ipa image not having the driver of the pxe interface
14:10:49 <hwoarang> #info ericsson pod2 issues because ipa image lacks driver for pxe interface
14:11:05 <david_Orange> mting on ericsson side add a new vlan for pxe on a compatible nic, i have to correct pdf/idf and test
14:11:36 <david_Orange> so for review, i will push a few enhancement in a few hours and it shall be good
14:12:01 <hwoarang> #info patches need an update before they are ready for reviews
14:12:19 <david_Orange> i will also test a deployement on VM on Baremeral to check it is not only functionnal on orange pods
14:12:59 <david_Orange> if i am not wrong we could deploy several virtual pods on the same server, avoiding VM in VM
14:14:02 <hwoarang> that's great!
14:14:11 <david_Orange> that is all, i will push a call for review quickly
14:14:30 <hwoarang> great thank you
14:14:46 <david_Orange> it will of course also be compatible with different flavors
14:14:56 <hwoarang> #topic Scenario/Feature Status: k8s in XCI
14:15:18 <hwoarang> so hw_wutianwei_ is on holidays and the proposed patchset didn't pass CI. needs discussion
14:15:40 <hwoarang> #info k8s+centos patch  doesn't pass CI
14:15:42 <hwoarang> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/51607/
14:16:01 <hwoarang> #info SUSE support for kubspray to be submitted upstream soon
14:16:32 <hwoarang> so that's it
14:16:49 <hwoarang> #topic Scenario/Feature Status: congress in XCI
14:16:57 <hwoarang> #info upstream patch got merged
14:17:00 <hwoarang> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/503971/
14:17:06 <hwoarang> #info needs XCI integration now
14:17:19 <hwoarang> #topic Scenario/Feature Status: os-odl-sfc
14:17:23 <hwoarang> mardim: mbuil^
14:17:35 <mbuil> hwoarang: one sec. https://review.openstack.org/#/c/503971/ is not merged yet :P
14:18:15 <hwoarang> right...
14:18:28 <mbuil> hwoarang: no news from my side
14:18:31 <hwoarang> almost there. it had possitive reviews and W+1 a while ago :p
14:18:46 <hwoarang> mardim: anything on your end?
14:19:23 <mardim> hwoarang, yes
14:19:32 <mardim> hwoarang, I ve found a bug
14:20:00 <mardim> hwoarang, which this patch tries to solve https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/52197/
14:20:08 <mardim> that's all from me
14:20:11 <mardim> thanks
14:20:44 <hwoarang> yep but that's unrelated to sfc right?
14:21:12 <mardim> hwoarang, ah yes sorry
14:21:16 <hwoarang> no problem
14:21:22 <mardim> hwoarang, nothing for sfc from my side
14:21:38 <hwoarang> #topic Scenario/Feature Status: os-odl-bgpvpn
14:21:40 <hwoarang> epalper: ^
14:22:56 <epalper> hwoarang: sorry, was in another meeting
14:23:22 <epalper> waiting for your review comments on https://review.openstack.org/#/c/523907/
14:23:38 <hwoarang> #info upstream patch is waiting for reviews
14:23:42 <hwoarang> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/523907/
14:24:04 <epalper> raised xci review https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/48705/ for this scenario
14:24:26 <hwoarang> #info XCI integration patchset is ready for reviews
14:24:30 <hwoarang> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/48705/
14:24:43 <epalper> that's all from me
14:25:06 <hwoarang> thank you epalper
14:25:15 <hwoarang> #topic AOB
14:25:33 <hwoarang> #info no meeting on the 28th of Feb due to OpenStack PTG
14:25:43 <hwoarang> anything else that you want to raise?
14:25:54 <jmorgan1> who will be at Openstack
14:26:15 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Victor Morales proposed releng-xci: Add proxy support  https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/45383
14:26:24 <hwoarang> fatih and myself afaik
14:27:47 <electrocucaracha> hwoarang: so regarding the discussion about Kolla, is this going to be postpone?
14:28:16 <hwoarang> electrocucaracha: it was not on the agenda so i didn't raise this topic
14:28:34 <hwoarang> does it need to happen during this meeting?
14:29:04 <electrocucaracha> well, last time we agreed to discuss it when there was more quorum
14:29:42 <hwoarang> electrocucaracha: if you want to discuss, the stage is yours :)
14:30:11 <david_Orange> the idea of fatih was to vote about kolla, maybe we can plan it after the PTG ?
14:30:31 <jmorgan1> what needs to be voted on?
14:30:48 <david_Orange> the introduction of kolla as another installer
14:32:05 <jmorgan1> the idea of adding kolla support to xci is already done (imo), the implementation is what was being discussed
14:32:22 <jmorgan1> as you have three different people working on it in three different ways
14:32:25 <hwoarang> so fatih said he would send an email about that in the tech-discuss but i can't see it.
14:33:01 <jmorgan1> i don't know if he is the right person to do so as he is not the one who is promoting kolla, no?
14:33:27 <david_Orange> we dont have really 3 way of installing it, as i understood we all use vanilla kolla
14:33:33 <hwoarang> don't know i am just reading last week's logs
14:34:09 <jmorgan1> hwoarang: np, just sharing my opinion ;)
14:34:50 <david_Orange> fdegir asked us to write arguments for kolla here https://etherpad.opnfv.org/p/xci-kolla
14:35:15 <david_Orange> it seems that it is completed
14:35:47 <fdegir> jmorgan1: the team has to have conversation around this and vote
14:36:11 <electrocucaracha> actually the mbuil questions were answered
14:36:16 <fdegir> jmorgan1: if there are concerns raised by team members, they need to be answered
14:37:19 <david_Orange> fdegir, maybe we can now plan a vote date
14:37:53 <fdegir> david_Orange: yes, I am planning to have it on march 7th when everyone is back - from Chinese new year holiday and openstack PTG
14:38:12 <mbuil> electrocucaracha: thanks for answering :). I need to add an extra question :)
14:38:12 <jmorgan1> the vote is on if we add kolla support to xci or not?
14:38:45 <fdegir> jmorgan1: yes, that's it
14:39:31 <jmorgan1> ok, makes sense now. thanks
14:39:42 <david_Orange> about 7th i am on holiday, but will do my best to connect
14:40:04 <fdegir> jmorgan1: so we establish a light process to let the team know about what the new thing is, what it brings so they can take informed decisions
14:40:10 <hwoarang> voting can be done over email right? but if it's about discussion then that's a different issue
14:40:42 <fdegir> hwoarang: we can do it during the meeting - I'll send mail before march 7th meeting to highlight the vote
14:40:48 <hwoarang> ok then
14:40:58 * fdegir goes back to his other meeting now...
14:41:22 <hwoarang> ok
14:41:27 <hwoarang> anything else apart from kolla? :)
14:42:01 <hwoarang> ok then
14:42:11 <hwoarang> thank you for joining! see you in 2 weeks
14:42:11 <hwoarang> #endmeeting