18:00:39 #startmeeting tsc 18:00:39 Meeting started Thu Jan 29 18:00:39 2015 UTC. The chair is phrobb. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html. 18:00:39 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 18:00:39 The meeting name has been set to 'tsc' 18:01:09 #info dlenrow 18:01:10 #topic Roll Call TSC members please #info in 18:01:15 #info dlenrow 18:01:17 ooh celebrity chair death match? 18:01:18 #info colindixon 18:01:23 #info regXboi 18:01:25 #info Chris Wright 18:01:28 #info Youcef Laribi 18:01:28 #info Chris Price 18:01:36 #chair colindixon dfarrell07 ChrisPriceAB 18:01:36 Current chairs: ChrisPriceAB colindixon dfarrell07 phrobb 18:01:39 #info edwarnicke 18:01:43 #link https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/TSC:Main#Agenda the agend in it’s usual place 18:01:47 #info LuisGomez 18:01:59 #link https://meetings.opendaylight.org/opendaylight-meeting/2015/tsc/opendaylight-meeting-tsc.2015-01-22-18.00.html last weeks meeting agend for action item 18:02:00 #info vishnoianil 18:02:15 #undo ? 18:02:20 yeah^^ 18:02:20 #undo 18:02:20 Removing item from minutes: 18:02:31 #undo vishnoianil 18:02:32 vishnoianil: not a TSC member today, I don’t think 18:02:41 * regXboi notes he lacks magical chair powers 18:02:42 #info kwatsen 18:03:07 i thought it is for all the member who joins meeting, sorry for that :) 18:03:16 #action colindixon to continue to follow AD-SAL deprecation between VTN, OVSDB, and controller (are ther others?) 18:03:21 hopefully i am allowed to listen in :) 18:03:28 #action colindixon and TSC to elaborate on proper procedure for removal of committers from a project 18:03:42 vishnoianil: it's a public meeting - you can listen and comment (and please do so) 18:03:48 vishnoianil: yes you are :) 18:03:55 the records have to show which TSC members are here 18:03:58 * ChrisPriceAB vishnoianil that's been my assumption for over a year... 18:04:22 ChrisPriceAB, thank god, i thought i was about to be thrown out :D 18:04:36 * edwarnicke feels we should encourage listening ;) 18:04:44 * edwarnicke and talking :) 18:05:02 * ChrisPriceAB and donuts 18:05:06 you can also talk vishnoianil :) 18:05:09 #info ebrjohn Brady Johnson, SFC Project Lead 18:05:09 #info mohnish anumala 18:05:11 * regXboi and cookies! 18:05:18 vishnoianil: confusingly, some projects like OPNFV use #info for *everyone*. I personally don't think that's a great idea, but whatever. 18:05:28 * regXboi begs for chair 18:05:32 #chair regXboi 18:05:32 Current chairs: ChrisPriceAB colindixon dfarrell07 phrobb regXboi 18:05:32 phrobb: please chair me 18:05:34 * ChrisPriceAB odl #cookies 18:05:44 now this will be fun 18:05:48 #undo 18:05:48 Removing item from minutes: 18:05:51 #undo 18:05:51 Removing item from minutes: 18:05:51 ChrisPriceAB yum 18:05:57 ok all better 18:06:12 #action phrobb will send results from the condorcet poll on service releases 18:06:13 #info mohnish anumala (to replace) 18:06:20 colindixon: thanks 18:06:22 * ChrisPriceAB probb, thinking we have a winner for the next hack fest 18:06:26 #topic updates 18:06:27 #info jmedved 18:06:32 regXboi: as a test of the CIVS url I've sent it to you.. .can you try it and let me know you can get to it? 18:06:47 phrobb: let me give it a spin 18:06:49 * ChrisPriceAB will audio in in about 5 minutes... 18:07:12 #info The CFP for the ODL summit is next friday (2/6), we currently have only 6 submissions 18:07:35 * dfarrell07 will submit CFP thing soon, sorry for always being late phrobb 18:07:36 #action all people should submit more things if they have good/interestion ones 18:07:55 phrobb: this is for summer summit, right? 18:07:58 * ChrisPriceAB ooh, I think I want to increase that # 18:08:06 cdub: this is for the summer yeah 18:08:12 lol 18:08:23 cdub yes 18:08:29 #topic Helium-SR2 release 18:08:31 phrobb, colindixon: tnx 18:08:42 phrobb: I have an oven and I'm not afraid to use it :) 18:08:56 jmedved: that's the wrong message! 18:09:00 ;) 18:09:02 * tbachman sruns into meeting… l8 again :( 18:09:13 #char tbachman 18:09:17 char? 18:09:19 lol 18:09:20 lol 18:09:21 me is charred 18:09:23 lol... tbachman ouch 18:09:23 #chair tbachman 18:09:23 Current chairs: ChrisPriceAB colindixon dfarrell07 phrobb regXboi tbachman 18:09:30 :) 18:09:38 https://www.irccloud.com/#!/ircs://irc.freenode.net:6697/%23opendaylight-meeting 18:09:41 phrobb: yes I saw that link 18:09:48 now if I can just get webex to work :( 18:09:53 #info the build is out and we called for people to test 18:09:57 regXboi: cool, so you see the full results? 18:10:02 #link https://nexus.opendaylight.org/content/repositories/staging/org/opendaylight/integration/distribution-karaf/0.2.2-Helium-SR2/ 18:10:05 #Info no negativee reporting 18:10:10 phrobb: so I got the mail and I can see the link and yes I can see the results 18:10:20 regXboi: Thanks! 18:10:22 in 18:10:25 tbachman: on webex, join the club, we'll get 18:10:31 lol 18:10:31 phrobb: welcome 18:10:43 #info LuisGomez said that we found some new bugs, but the projects were notified and chose not to fix them in the release 18:10:57 #info otherwise, there are no regressions 18:11:06 #info LuisGomez says that one clustering test is running today in integration 18:11:11 #info edwarnicke asks if the tests are passing 18:11:30 #info LuisGomez says it’s passing but isn’t stable (?) 18:11:38 #link https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/release/2015-January/001261.html thread with responses about testing 18:12:12 "sort of bless" 18:12:16 * tbachman has spotty internetz at the moment 18:12:30 let's go with strong language...mostly, kinda bless 18:12:32 cdub: is that more like a ~1 instead of -1 or 0? 18:12:36 no objection 18:12:41 #info colindixon calls for the TSC to "sort of bless" the helium SR2 artifacts 18:12:46 lol 18:13:04 heh 18:13:08 #agree the TSC the artifacts in the link above will be published as helium SR2 artifacts 18:13:20 regXboi: thx — my modem must be doing a FW update or something :( 18:13:25 #action gzhao to work with tykeal to promote the correct set of artifacts 18:13:38 Congratulations! 18:13:49 what are we congratulating? 18:13:49 #topic lithium and stable helium - other issues 18:13:51 SR2? 18:14:09 #info zxiiro removed packetcable from the autorelease b/c it was failing the build 18:14:16 #info there is now a working Lithium daily auot release, but had to remove packetcable 18:14:30 tbachman: Helium SR2 18:14:32 #info there are test failures, that haven’t been expored yet 18:14:33 hideyuki: thx! 18:14:57 #undo 18:14:57 Removing item from minutes: 18:15:03 #info there are test failures, that haven’t been explored yet 18:15:21 #info gzhao has not received contact from person identified who is supposed to take over the packetcable project 18:15:31 #undo 18:15:31 Removing item from minutes: 18:15:46 #info gzhao has not yet been contacted by person identified to take over packetcable project 18:15:49 #action gzhao colindixon to work out what the next Helium SR and the target dates 18:16:31 #info packetcable is the only Helium project not yet joined Lithium 18:16:50 #info colindixon asks which projects voted 18:16:55 #info colindixon asks if projects have been received from all projects, and if the project voted and said they didn’t want to support a previous release, which projects were they 18:17:02 #undo 18:17:02 Removing item from minutes: 18:17:10 * ChrisPriceAB :P 18:17:16 * ChrisPriceAB yours was much better 18:17:59 lol 18:18:06 Fabiel Zuniga is from HP 18:18:10 #action phrobb to figure which projects (if any) didn’t respond and of the ones that did which ones say they woudln’t want to support at least one release 18:18:11 persistence project 18:18:35 ChrisPriceAB: thx ;) 18:18:57 except for my use of “projects” in place of “responses” :o 18:19:24 tbachman: i missed it, what's the issue/concern with the persistence project? 18:19:52 uchau: colindixon was asking phrobb about which projects had replied about not supporting a release () 18:19:52 ? 18:19:55 something along those lines 18:20:06 phrobb: couldn’t remember the project that Fabiel was part of 18:20:09 sorry 18:20:18 uchau: phrobb couldn’t remember the project that Fabiel was part of 18:20:32 * ChrisPriceAB would have but don't qualify ;) 18:20:33 #info colindixon asks who voted for only the current release, which would be Lithium 18:20:51 phrobb says Persistence, PCMM, and what was the last one? 18:20:58 * tbachman has super-ugly internetz 18:21:03 feels like 9600, all over again 18:21:06 Is it not only stable releases for the current release, not the pending release ? 18:21:33 Lithium doesn't exist yet... :s 18:21:50 ChrisPriceAB: I agree that pending release would be clearer 18:21:52 tbachman: Michal Polkorab, openflow java 18:21:57 gzhao: thx! 18:21:59 but it’s the current release we’re working twoard 18:22:22 #topic System Integration & Test 18:22:22 #info phrobb says Persistence, PacketCable, and OpenFlow Plugin 18:22:24 ugh 18:22:25 lol 18:22:29 sorry 18:22:47 * regXboi has no clue 18:22:57 * ChrisPriceAB ooh me too 18:23:09 LuisGomez: thanks for a #info 18:23:13 LuisGomez: will post a #info 18:23:35 #info the last two days (Tue and Wed) were an integration meeting 18:23:56 #info integration project gathered to discuss the strategy for the current release. 18:23:56 #info there were 10-12 attendees each day, talked about the key areas for this release 18:24:01 Some folks came in for lunch as well :) 18:24:18 abhijitkumbhare: :p 18:24:26 #link https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/CrossProject:Integration_Group:Lithium_Test_Strategy artifact created during Integration Gathering this week 18:24:28 * ChrisPriceAB weren't talking about you abhijit 18:24:28 #link https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/CrossProject:Integration_Group:Lithium_Test_Strategy 18:24:33 #undo 18:24:33 Removing item from minutes: 18:24:34 dfarrell07: saves the day again 18:24:38 :) 18:24:46 my IRC is fine 18:24:46 #Info also finalized the integration release plan 18:24:51 webex sounds like an old video game 18:24:52 :) ChrisPriceAB 18:24:55 colindixon: it looks like AAA is going to need another vote on project lead 18:25:09 regXboi: huh, OK 18:25:10 good to know 18:25:20 colindixon: email just came to TSC list 18:25:49 #topic Infrastructure 18:26:25 #info phrobb reports all projects have been migrated to rackspace 18:26:41 #info phrobbs that transition to jjb is still ongoing 18:26:44 #info we’re working on getting everyone (ideally) into JJB 18:26:44 #undo 18:26:44 Removing item from minutes: 18:26:48 #undo 18:26:48 Removing item from minutes: 18:26:51 * colindixon will stop 18:26:55 lol 18:26:56 28 as of this morning 18:27:07 #info we’re working on getting everyone (ideally) into JJB 18:27:10 #info 28 projects have migrated to JJB 18:27:19 * regXboi likes colindixon's info, just wanted to get rid of his own 18:27:24 colindixon: FYI for AAA - Liem has moved to a new team at HP. HP has 2 new developers who will be working on AAA code. 18:27:25 yeah 18:27:54 bigalh: ok… let’s handle this on the TSC list 18:28:04 * bigalh agrees. 18:28:07 just an FYI 18:28:23 yes, 28 from Lithium, 31 total in JJB tabs 18:28:58 #info phrobb wants to know if there are things that we should be doing beyond getting people to JJB, also should we reach out to others 18:29:41 #info edwarnicke says that JJB has been pretty smooth sailing even from some very complicated projects 18:30:01 #info abhijitkumbhare asks if migration to JJB can be a TWS topic 18:30:19 #action zxiiro to work with alagalah to schedule a TWS call on moving to JJB 18:30:30 colindixon: straight to action :) 18:30:43 * ChrisPriceAB actionman??? 18:30:59 #manofaction 18:31:11 :D 18:31:13 #link https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/RelEng:Jenkins#Basic_Job_Configuration the wiki page documenting JJB using 18:31:35 #info regXboi says he missed when we switched from JJB being optional to what sounds like a requirement for Lithium 18:31:54 #info colindixon says that no project is required to move to JJB; no one has said no to migration, tho 18:33:03 #info if your build is really just “mvn clean install”, the section above will work really, really well and take < 30 minutes 18:34:00 lol 18:35:23 * regXboi goes back to sleep again 18:35:40 #info LuisGomez sent a mail to clarify M2 question for projects: “Project will use OpenDaylight CI Infrastructure?” should say: “Project will use OpenDaylight CI Infrastructure for their System Test?” 18:35:49 gzhao: cat herder extraordinaire! 18:35:54 LuisGomez: thanks! 18:35:55 * Neelajacques doesn't love the phrase "stick George on people" 18:36:08 * tbachman is going to dissappear for a sec… hoping that modem reboot fixes his lousy internetz 18:36:13 Neelajacques: :p 18:36:22 lol 18:36:29 gzhao knows what I mean 18:36:38 * ChrisPriceAB has a healthy fear of having george stck to me... :s 18:36:51 * regXboi looks for tbachman to rematerialize 18:36:59 #action zxiiro will create patches for project than haven’t haven’t moved and gzhao would help shepherd people 18:38:01 #info on the monday TWS call, Ed demoed some cool stuff demoing with archetypes that rely on having a settings.xml file 18:38:47 #info so far, our infrastructure didn’t have that, but now it does so that projects generated with these archetype will work in our build infrastructure 18:39:37 wb tbachman 18:40:07 #info it also seems like to get into maven central, we need to remove the tags in their pom files anyway, so we’d have to move in this direction if we want to publish stuff into maven central 18:40:11 bigalh: thx! 18:40:11 * tbachman hopes his 9600 baud moment is over 18:40:24 lol 18:40:37 :( 18:40:50 #link https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/release/2015-January/001264.html more details including how to get a settings.xml file on your computer 18:40:51 * tbachman wonders if the new “smart meter” that was just installed is causing problems :( 18:41:43 * regXboi wonders if we need a "technical debt janitor project" 18:41:48 lol 18:42:16 #info LuisGomez says that there is a very real possibility that we might need ~40 or even more VMs to handle tests on bursts 18:42:49 #info tykeal says that our current VM max is 250, we’ve bursted as high as 90 VMs 18:43:17 #info tykeal we are now allowed to use up to 768 GB of RAM (!!!!) because we were going over 0.5 TB 18:43:59 #info that is across all slaves, not per VM 18:44:21 #info the largest slave comes up with 8 GB of RAM for a VM 18:46:14 #topic committer promotions 18:46:57 hehe 18:47:10 #Info Brady Johnson as a committer on SFC 18:47:26 #link https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/sfc-dev/2015-January/000748.html by my count earlier 10/12 current committers to SFC voted +1 18:47:43 do we have a link to the stackalitics? 18:47:53 I'm looking for it 18:47:59 #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/q/status:merged+project:sfc+owner:%22Brady+Johnson+%253Cbrady.allen.johnson%2540ericsson.com%253E%22 - Brady's merges to SFC 18:48:30 hehe 18:48:51 I don't know why either :-/ 18:48:59 spectrometer (not stacalytics) and it doesn't have sfc 18:49:12 #startvote Shall the TSC approve Brady Johnson as a committer on the SFC project? -1, 0, +1 18:49:12 Begin voting on: Shall the TSC approve Brady Johnson as a committer on the SFC project? Valid vote options are -1, 0, +1. 18:49:12 Vote using '#vote OPTION'. Only your last vote counts. 18:49:16 #vote +1 18:49:16 #vote +1 18:49:17 #vote +1 18:49:18 #vote +1 18:49:20 #vote +1 18:49:20 #vote +1 18:49:20 #vote +1 18:49:25 #vote +1 18:49:27 #vote +1 18:49:35 #vote +1 18:49:43 #link uuuuugh 18:49:43 #endvote 18:49:43 Voted on "Shall the TSC approve Brady Johnson as a committer on the SFC project?" Results are 18:49:43 +1 (10): dlenrow, regXboi, LuisGomez, edwarnicke, ChrisPriceAB, cdub, mohnish, kwatsen, colindixon, Youcef 18:49:59 #info congratulations 18:50:12 #agreed Brady Johnson is approved as a committer on the SFC project 18:50:19 #topic creation reviews 18:50:23 Thank you everybody, its an honor to work with you guys :) 18:50:30 congrats ebrjohn 18:50:38 * ChrisPriceAB can't help being from colorado! 18:50:39 ebrjohn: Congratz :) 18:50:39 congrats and well deserved 18:50:46 ebrjohn: congratulations 18:51:00 ebrjohn: w00t! 18:51:12 ebrjohn: Its about time! ;) 18:51:18 :) 18:51:19 congrats 18:51:26 Congrats ebrjohn :) 18:51:40 * ebrjohn doing a little victory dance ;) 18:51:49 lol 18:51:49 * ChrisPriceAB stop that!!! 18:52:24 ChrisPriceAB - I thought ebrjohn was from Texas - so I guess he cannot go for the pot :) 18:52:46 #info intent is requesting to join Lithium as an offset 2 project by providing a final release plan by the 2/5 deadline 18:52:47 regXboi: is obviously on a 600 baud modem ;) 18:53:00 #shall the TSC approve the NIC project to join the Lithium simultaneous release as an offset 2 project? -1, 0, +1 18:53:03 * edwarnicke feeds his carrier pidgeons 18:53:07 #vote +1 18:53:14 * ChrisPriceAB abhijitkumbhare these transients you know... 18:53:18 #vote shall the TSC approve the NIC project to join the Lithium simultaneous release as an offset 2 project? -1, 0, +1 18:53:28 it's #startvote 18:53:34 #startvote irc://irc.freenode.net:6667/#shall the TSC approve the NIC project to join the Lithium simultaneous release as an offset 2 project? -1, 0, +1 18:53:34 Begin voting on: irc://irc.freenode.net:6667/#shall the TSC approve the NIC project to join the Lithium simultaneous release as an offset 2 project? Valid vote options are -1, 0, +1. 18:53:34 Vote using '#vote OPTION'. Only your last vote counts. 18:53:41 #vote +1 18:53:44 #vote +1 18:53:45 #vote +1 18:53:50 #vote +1 18:53:51 #vote +1 18:53:51 #vote +1 18:53:52 #vote +1 18:53:54 #vote +1 18:53:55 #vote +1 18:53:55 #vote +1 18:53:59 #vote +1 18:54:02 #endvote 18:54:02 Voted on "irc://irc.freenode.net:6667/#shall the TSC approve the NIC project to join the Lithium simultaneous release as an offset 2 project?" Results are 18:54:02 +1 (11): dlenrow, jmedved, regXboi, LuisGomez, edwarnicke, ChrisPriceAB, cdub, mohnish, kwatsen, colindixon, Youcef 18:54:15 #agreed NIC can join lithium 18:54:17 * ChrisPriceAB congrats IBN?NIC? project 18:54:21 Congratulations! 18:54:25 ChrisPriceAB: NIC. 18:54:25 congrats 18:54:43 * ChrisPriceAB the regXboi has spoken... 18:54:46 * dfarrell07 wonders how hard it is to alias [#vote, #shall, ...] to #startvote 18:54:48 Congrats NIC 18:54:56 * Neelajacques Super glad we now have Network Interface Card project .. oh wait... 18:55:04 * ChrisPriceAB hehe 18:55:11 Neelajacques: You win the thread ;) 18:55:30 #link https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/project-proposals/2015-January/000251.html this project proposal wants to be reviewed on 2/12 to joint lithium as a spin-out project before M3 18:55:36 Next we'll invent ethernet. Sorry metcalf 18:55:58 * ChrisPriceAB process is to vote at TSC for that? (looking for clarification) 18:56:01 #info the controller project has bee consulted and covered very politely and happil 18:56:29 #topic Java 8 18:56:55 #info it turns out to get Java 8 to work, we need to upgrade from Karaf 3.0.1 to 3.0.2 or later 18:57:14 #info they are working on that and dealing with a few hiccups 18:57:27 #info projects should use karaf parent to simplify the process. 18:57:53 #info this will be much easier if projects use karaf-parent (which requires settings.xml) as the parent for their local karaf distributions 18:58:40 #topic COOKIES 18:58:49 #endmeeting